Top Stories

Toilet use based on biological sex, says Phillipson

Aleks Phillips
BBC News

Trans women should use toilets according to their biological sex, the equalities minister has said.

In response to the UK Supreme Court's ruling that a woman is legally defined by biological sex, Bridget Phillipson stopped short of saying trans women should use the men's toilets.

But she told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "The ruling was clear that provisions and services should be accessed on the basis of biological sex."

Pushed further for clarification on whether a trans woman should use the men's or women's toilets she repeated: "The ruling is clear."

Phillipson said the law on trans women accessing single-sex spaces on the basis of biological sex "would apply right across the board".

But she stressed that the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) "will be setting out additional guidance and a statutory code of practice, because we need to make sure that everyone has the ability to access services that are safe and appropriate, and respect their privacy and dignity".

In particular, there needed to be "appropriate and available services for all people, including trans people" when it came to settings such as hospitals and changing rooms.

Pressed on what the ruling meant for trans women looking to use a toilet today, she responded: "The ruling was clear that provisions and services should be accessed on the basis of biological sex.

"But I know that many businesses large and small will ensure that they have appropriate provision in place, for example many businesses have moved towards unisex provision or separate cubicles that can be used by anyone."

The EHRC has already suggested trans people should use their "powers of advocacy" to campaign for so-called third spaces that are gender neutral to avoid these sorts of dilemmas.

Phillipson, who is also education secretary, said many places had unisex toilets or individual cubicles.

"Go into your local cafe, a local family cafe - [the] chances are that they'll have one cubicle that's self-contained that can be used by anyone," she added.

Campaign group For Women Scotland, which brought the case, warned that interpreting "sex" as gender identity under the law would have implications for the running of single-sex spaces and services, such as hospital wards, prisons, refuges and support groups.

The decision by the Supreme Court found the biological interpretation of sex was required for single-sex spaces - which can include changing rooms, hostels and medical services - to "function coherently".

However, single-sex spaces could exclude people with gender recognition certificates (GRCs) - which give legal status to a transgender person's gender identity - "if it is proportionate to do so", the judges ruled.

Transgender people have said the ruling may erode the protections they have against discrimination in their reassigned gender - protections the judges said they had under other parts of the Equality Act.

Phillipson, who managed a women's refuge before becoming an MP, said it was important that "women – especially those who have experienced male violence, sexual violence and trauma – are able to access safe, therapeutic spaces" while ensuring that "everyone in our society is treated with dignity and respect".

She said these women-only spaces could now be "confident as to how they deliver services" as the Supreme Court had "set that beyond doubt".

Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has also welcomed the ruling, telling ITV West Country: "A woman is an adult female, and the court has made that absolutely clear."

He said the ruling "gives real clarity" and would inform guidance.

"It's a welcome step forward. It's real clarity in an area where we did need clarity, I'm pleased it's come about."


Source link

Leave A Comment


Last Visited Articles


Info Board

Visitor Counter
0
 

Todays visit

41 Articles 5943 RSS ARTS 106 Photos

Popular News

🚀 Welcome to our website! Stay updated with the latest news. 🎉

United States

18.189.184.40 :: Total visit:


Welcome 58.589.584.40 Click here to Register or login
Oslo time:2025-04-22 Whos is online (last 10 min): 
1 - United States - 18.189.184.41
2 - Singapore - 47.828.882.885
3 - United States - 66.269.66.628
4 - Singapore - 44.428.45.242
5 - United States - 66.247.64.732
6 - Singapore - 47.628.62.202
7 - United States - 236.244.66.237
8 - Singapore - 224.229.222.265
9 - Singapore - 47.228.52.232
10 - United States - 20.070.207.045
11 - Singapore - 47.338.37.304
12 - United States - 2a03:2880:f800:16::
13 - United States - 2a03:2990:f900:9d::
14 - Singapore - 47.728.57.86
15 - Singapore - 888.889.838.38
16 - Singapore - 47.728.37.87
17 - Singapore - 47.628.25.224
18 - France - 54.36.343.356
19 - Singapore - 17.128.115.161
20 - United States - 2a73:2887:f877:2::
21 - United States - 3a33:3883:f833:d::
22 - United States - 857.55.89.80
23 - Singapore - 47.008.04.34
24 - Singapore - 554.559.535.258
25 - United States - 66.269.60.32
26 - United States - 0a03:0000:00ff:4d::
27 - United States - 236.244.66.200
28 - United States - 6.646.266.66
29 - Singapore - 00.028.22.200
30 - France - 54.36.048.065
31 - Singapore - 47.328.97.248
32 - Singapore - 97.928.58.985
33 - Singapore - 17.128.121.222
34 - United States - 66.249.70.34
35 - United States - 66.249.76.33
36 - United States - 52.337.344.374
37 - Singapore - 47.328.25.397
38 - United States - 2a53:2885:f855:8::
39 - United States - 2a63:2886:63ff::
40 - United States - 52.35.32.83
41 - Singapore - 47.028.40.000
42 - United States - 44.295.245.202
43 - United States - 55.0.63.555
44 - Singapore - 47.828.49.94
45 - Singapore - 47.028.000.050
46 - Singapore - 47.727.725.75
47 - Singapore - 47.428.35.424
48 - United Kingdom - 242.252.242.242
49 - Singapore - 334.339.336.208
50 - Singapore - 47.929.44.934
51 - United States - 66.229.62.229
52 - Singapore - 41.121.122.115
53 - Singapore - 49.928.36.994
54 - France - 54.36.448.85
55 - Singapore - 47.626.63.249
56 - Singapore - 774.779.736.88


Farsi English Norsk RSS